Self-Defense Leads to a Life Sentence in Georgia
August 21, 2010NAACP DEMANDS NEW TRIAL APPLAUDS DISSENTING OPINION OF GEORGIA SUPREME COURT CHIEF JUSTICE IN CASE
PRESS CONFERENCE GEORGIA STATE CAPITAL 11:30AM TUESDAY AUGUST 24TH
The North Carolina and Georgia State Conferences of the NAACP, joined by the National NAACP, will hold a press conference Tuesday, August 24 on the steps of the Georgia State Capitol (Washington Street side) at 11:30 AM to address the wrongful conviction of Mr. John McNeil by the Georgia system of 'justice.' The two State Conferences and the National NAACP will visit Mr. McNeil at the Hancock State Prison prior to the press conference and will release the powerful dissent of the Chief Justice of Georgia's Supreme Court in Mr. McNeil's case. "How is it that in America, a person can receive a life sentence for defending his life and that of his child, from an armed attacker?" stated NAACP President and CEO Benjamin Todd Jealous. "The conviction and sentencing of John McNeil is a case the courts must reexamine. As American citizens we have the right to defend our homes, our lives and our families without the threat of excessive jail sentences. We stand with the NC and GA NAACP State Conferences as they demand justice for John McNeil," concluded Jealous.
John McNeil, a father who was defending his teenage son, himself, and his home, was convicted and sentenced to life in prison in November 2006 for killing Brian Epp, a white trespasser. The Chief Justice of the Georgia Supreme Court found that Epp, an armed trespasser on McNeil’s property had already threatened McNeil’s son with a box cutter. When McNeil arrived home to protect his son, he told the trespasser to get off the McNeil property. Eyewitnesses saw the trespasser, with the box cutter still on his person, keep advancing toward McNeil. McNeil warned him again, and when the trespasser got within a few feet of McNeil, the homeowner fired a warning shot into the ground. The trespasser continued to advance in a threatening manner toward McNeil, ignoring McNeil’s command to back up. When the trespasser was within arm's distance where he could injure or kill McNeil with the box cutter, or grab McNeil's weapon, McNeil fired one shot, which was fatal.
"Sir Edward Coke, an English jurist of the 17th century once said, ‘An Englishman's home is his castle'," said Rev. Dr. William J. Barber, II, NC NAACP State Conference President. "In Georgia, however, a black man's home is nothing. What happened to John McNeil in the Georgia courts is a cynical miscarriage of justice that must be overturned. His conviction and life sentence should convince every person of goodwill that we are sentenced to a life of struggle to dismantle the racism deeply rooted in our criminal justice system. If it can happen to John McNeil, it could happen to any of us" concluded Rev. Barber.
"After reviewing all the evidence in the John McNeil case, I am convinced that McNeil's only crime is that of being Black," stated Ed Dubose, NAACP Georgia State Conference President. "The fact that a black homeowner, on his own property, defending his son from a trespasser wielding a box cutter could be given a life sentence is a grim reminder of how unequal the scales of justice really are. We will continue in the fight for Mr. McNeil and his family until justice prevails," Dubose concluded.
We trust that when the public learns the details of the evidence as recited by the Chief Justice of the Georgia Supreme Court there will be a national and international movement for a new trial for Mr. McNeil.
Founded in 1909, the NAACP is the nation's oldest and largest civil rights organization. Its members throughout the United States and the world are the premier advocates for civil rights in their communities, conducting voter mobilization and monitoring equal opportunity in the public and private sectors.
###
